Project Summary
Who Would Win Masters is a weekly geek culture debate podcast where guests compete by representing their favorite fictional characters in structured 3-round battles. Its Beat Bobby Flay, for Geek Debate Club. Co-hosted with Ray Stakenas, I guide each episode as the referee and Host, helping shape the flow of the match while keeping the audience engaged throughout.
Each episode ends with my informal verdict on the winner, while the official decision is determined by the Patreon community. The show has evolved into an ongoing interactive format that blends debate, fandom, and audience participation.
Now in it’s second season and closing in on 100+ episodes.
Why It Matters
This project turns fandom debate into an ongoing competitive format, combining structured storytelling, recurring guest appearances, and community-driven outcomes. With 50+ episodes and a growing tournament arc, it demonstrates sustained audience engagement and a scalable episodic format built around participation.
My Role
- Writer
- Producer
- Host
- Video Editor
- Social Media Manager
- Community Manager
- Graphic Design
What I Did
- Developed and structured the weekly debate format and 3-round battle system
- Co-hosted episodes and guided narrative flow between debates
- Edited episodes for pacing, clarity, and entertainment value
- Managed guest coordination and booking
- Created daily social content promoting episodes, guests, and themes
- Engaged and moderated community discussions across platforms
- Helped design and run Patreon-based voting and decision-making system
- Supported development of seasonal tournament arcs
What Made This Project Special
The show blends structured debate with fandom storytelling, turning fictional “what if” arguments into an ongoing competitive series. The Patreon voting system adds a layer of audience ownership, making viewers part of the final outcome rather than passive listeners.
The introduction of tournament arcs and guest-vs-guest matchups expanded the format beyond episodic content into a larger evolving competition.
Skills Demonstrated
- Live and recorded podcast production
- Audience engagement and community building
- Content strategy and episodic format design
- Social media promotion and audience growth
- Editing and post-production storytelling
- Talent coordination and guest management
- Interactive media and voting systems
Media Notes
- Embedded podcast episodes (YouTube / audio platform)
- Clips of key debate moments and highlight reels
- Tournament bracket visuals
- Social media posts promoting matchups and results
- Patreon voting interface or screenshots (if available)
Discover more from Sam Proof
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.